Why This List Works Right Now
Nobody Wants This reignited TV’s love for grounded romance that is equal parts messy and meaningful, which means your watchlist needs shows with sharp chemistry, real grown up stakes, and jokes that do not kill the feeling. These picks lean into opposites attract, complicated families, culture clash, and second chances, so your queue never loses the cozy spark that made Noah and Joanne so addictive.
What Nobody Wants This Is In One Line
An outspoken agnostic podcaster falls for an unconventional rabbi and both discover that love can be honest, awkward, and wildly worth it. Season 2 doubled down on heart and humor, so it is no wonder everyone is hunting the next great comfort watch with bite.
Fleabag
- Why you will love it: Forbidden chemistry with a priest, fourth wall wit, and emotional honesty that sneaks up on you.
- Vibe match: Sharp, modern, complicated desire meets rules and ritual, just like Noah and Joanne’s tug of war.
Catastrophe
- Why you will love it: Two adults thrown together by an unexpected pregnancy figure out love the hard way with gallows humor.
- Vibe match: Grown up choices, families with opinions, and two people who choose each other in spite of the noise.
Platonic
- Why you will love it: A messy, hilarious midlife friendship that asks if love can be complicated without being romantic.
- Vibe match: Smart banter and real consequences wrapped in breezy half hours that feel like a glass of wine after work.
Love
- Why you will love it: A prickly pair try to make it work in Los Angeles with tiny wins, big slips, and sly humor.
- Vibe match: Imperfect people trying on better versions of themselves one episode at a time.
Starstruck
- Why you will love it: A London meet cute with a movie star turns into a stop start romance that feels intimate and real.
- Vibe match: Chemistry first, career chaos second, and a city that feels like a third character.
New Girl
- Why you will love it: Found family, slow burn couples, and laugh out loud set pieces that age like comfort food.
- Vibe match: If you want cozy roommates plus crisp romance beats, this is the blanket show.
The Mindy Project
- Why you will love it: A chaotic, capable doctor juggles work, love, and her own delusions in candy colored half hours.
- Vibe match: Big personality heroine energy with quippy rom com DNA that still lands today.
Modern Love
- Why you will love it: Anthology romance inspired by real essays with A list casts and one episode tears.
- Vibe match: If you loved how Nobody Wants This balanced big feelings and small moments, this scratches the same itch.
Lovesick
- Why you will love it: Friends, exes, and second chances told with breezy British charm and a perfect theme song.
- Vibe match: Out of order storytelling that still lands the heart punch by the end of each season.
You’re The Worst
- Why you will love it: Two self sabotaging lovers try commitment with spectacularly bad timing and surprising tenderness.
- Vibe match: Spiky romance that lets flawed people earn softness, much like Noah and Joanne learning new rules.
Insecure
- Why you will love it: Issa and Molly navigate love, work, and friendship with music, humor, and honesty that hits.
- Vibe match: Adulting with receipts and relationships that evolve as fast as the jokes land.
Master Of None
- Why you will love it: Thoughtful dating stories, gorgeous episodes abroad, and an eye for modern love’s gray areas.
- Vibe match: If you crave grounded romance that respects silence and space, add it to the queue.
Togetherness
- Why you will love it: Indie tone, suburban ennui, and relationships under pressure that still find grace notes.
- Vibe match: For viewers who felt the ache under the jokes and want that same texture again.
Friends From College
- Why you will love it: Messy friend group, bad decisions, and the complicated math of history and attraction.
- Vibe match: If you like your rom coms a little toxic but truthful, this brings the chaos.
High Fidelity
- Why you will love it: A record store owner relives top five heartbreaks with needle drop perfection and razor banter.
- Vibe match: Romance filtered through taste culture and quietly huge confessions.
Normal People
- Why you will love it: Intimate, aching, impossible to stop watching, with performances that live in your head.
- Vibe match: If you want raw connection and long shadow love, this is a must.
Heartstopper
- Why you will love it: Pure joy, teen first loves, gentle humor, and artful little animations that make you smile.
- Vibe match: When you need the softest possible reset between heavier shows, choose this.
Please Like Me
- Why you will love it: Deadpan, heartfelt, queer coming of age that treats life’s mess with kindness and wit.
- Vibe match: Offbeat tone with big empathy, perfect after Nobody Wants This marathons.
The Marvelous Mrs Maisel
- Why you will love it: Comedy career glow up, period romance, and a heroine who refuses to apologize.
- Vibe match: Fast talk, big stakes, and family drama that still lets love breathe.
Shrinking
- Why you will love it: Therapists behaving badly, found family, and punchlines that sneak attack your feelings.
- Vibe match: Grief, love, and goofy optimism living in the same thirty minutes.
Where To Start If You Only Have One Night
- Fleabag for forbidden sparks done right.
- Catastrophe for grown up love with bite.
- Starstruck for cozy modern fairytale feels.
Fast Facts For Your Group Chat
- Nobody Wants This premiered in 2024 and returned with Season 2 in October 2025.
- The show pairs Kristen Bell and Adam Brody as an agnostic host and a rabbi navigating romance, family, and faith.
- Fans looking for similar comfort plus chemistry often push Fleabag, Love, and New Girl to the top of most lists.
How To Build A Perfect Weekend Queue
- Start with a spicy starter like Fleabag or Love, then cool down with Starstruck.
- Add a heartfelt anchor like Normal People or Modern Love for balance.
- End with New Girl or The Mindy Project to sleep smiling.
Calls To Action
- Share this with a friend who loves fashion and vote which lead has the best date night wardrobe.
- Don’t miss out, try a double feature tonight and report back with your chemistry scorecards.
- Drop your top three recs below so the whole thread leaves with a better queue.
Mini Matchups You Can Steal
- Fleabag vs Nobody Wants This: faith entanglements and impossible choices.
- Catastrophe vs Love: accidental life together vs accidental love that becomes a life.
- New Girl vs Starstruck: found family chaos vs slow burn celebrity romance.
If You Want Culture Clash Romance
- Try Fleabag and The Priest, Catastrophe’s cross Atlantic pairing, and Nobody Wants This’ rabbi meets rebel setup.
- Add Insecure for modern LA energy and relationships that grow up in public.
If You Want Millennial And Gen Z Comfort
- New Girl, Lovesick, and Heartstopper drop stress while keeping heart.
- Modern Love slots in for one perfect cry per night.
If You Want Career Girl Chaos
- The Mindy Project, High Fidelity, and Mrs Maisel deliver ambition plus attraction.
- Shrinking throws in therapy humor that actually heals you a little.
One Last Word On Nobody Wants This
The show works because it lets love be inconvenient, funny, and honest about belief, family, and what people owe themselves, and that is why these recommendations feel like true next steps. When a rom com understands timing as well as chemistry, you feel it in the group chat the next morning, and this list keeps that feeling rolling.
Closing Line
Comment with your perfect triple bill, tag your binge buddy, and follow for weekly recs that keep your queue romantic, chaotic, and ridiculously fun.
